Investigation 7

Cell Division: Mitosis and Meiosis

How do eukaryotic cells divide to produce genetically identical cells or to produce gametes with half the normal DNA?

Unit 4: Cell CycleUnit 5: HeredityIST-1.BIST-1.CIST-1.FIST-1.GScience Practices 1.B, 4.B, 5.A≈ 4–5 class periodsAbout 185 minutes in total
Overview

What you'll investigate

Every one of your trillions of cells came from a single zygote, and every egg or sperm you make carries exactly half of your chromosomes. In this lab you will model how chromosomes move in mitosis and meiosis, count dividing cells in onion root tips to test whether a fungal lectin speeds up mitosis, compare the chromosomes of normal and cancer cells, and use the fungus Sordaria fimicola to measure how often crossing over happens.

The investigation has five parts:

  1. Modeling mitosis with pop-bead chromosomes, then putting real cell images in order.
  2. Effects of environment on mitosis: score onion root-tip squashes from control and lectin-treated bulbs, pool class data, and run a chi-square test.
  3. Loss of cell cycle control in cancer: count and compare chromosomes in normal, HeLa, and leukemia karyotypes.
  4. Modeling meiosis with crossing over, independent assortment, and nondisjunction.
  5. Crossing over in Sordaria: score asci and calculate the gene-to-centromere map distance.
Learning objectives
  • IST-1.B Describe the events that occur in the cell cycle.
  • IST-1.C Explain how mitosis results in the transmission of chromosomes from one generation to the next.
  • IST-1.F Explain how meiosis results in the transmission of chromosomes from one generation to the next.
  • IST-1.G Describe similarities and differences between the phases and outcomes of mitosis and meiosis.

Science practices: 1.B explain biological concepts and processes · 4.B describe data from a table or graph · 5.A perform mathematical calculations (mitotic index, chi-square, map distance).

Safety in the real lab

Root-tip squashes use 1 M hydrochloric acid, Carnoy's fixative (glacial acetic acid and ethanol), and carbol-fuchsin stain, which contains phenol. Wear goggles and disposable gloves for Parts 2 and 5. Use a razor blade with care, and press cover slips with a pencil eraser through a lab wipe, never your thumb. Purified lectin can irritate skin and airways. Dispose of chemicals as your teacher directs.

Background

The cell cycle, its controls, and two kinds of division

Key ideas
  • The cell cycle is G1, S (DNA replication), G2 and M (mitosis plus cytokinesis). Interphase is G1 + S + G2 and takes most of the time.
  • Mitosis passes one full copy of every chromosome to each daughter, so the two cells are identical and keep 2n.
  • Cyclins, CDKs and three checkpoints control the cycle; cancer cells have lost this control.
  • Meiosis has two divisions after one S phase and makes four different haploid cells, through crossing over and independent assortment.
  • Mitotic index = dividing cells ÷ cells counted. Map distance = % crossover asci ÷ 2.

Bacteria and archaea divide by binary fission, and so do mitochondria and chloroplasts, which is one line of evidence that these organelles descended from free-living prokaryotes. Eukaryotic cells have a harder job: they must copy many linear chromosomes, sort the copies precisely, and split a large cytoplasm full of organelles. The sequence of events that does this is the cell cycle.

Interphase takes up most of the cycle. In G1 the cell grows and makes organelles. In S phase every chromosome is replicated, so each chromosome now consists of two identical sister chromatids held together at the centromere. In G2 the cell checks the new DNA and prepares to divide. A G2 cell has twice the DNA of a G1 cell but no new genetic information, because the sisters are copies. Cells that stop dividing leave the cycle and sit in G0.

In mitosis the condensed chromosomes line up at the metaphase plate, the sister chromatids are pulled to opposite poles by spindle microtubules attached at their kinetochores, and two nuclei form. Cytokinesis then splits the cytoplasm (a furrow in animal cells, a cell plate in plant cells). Condensing first matters: long, tangled interphase DNA would snag and break if it were dragged across the cell, like trying to separate cooked spaghetti, whereas compact chromosomes move like pieces of macaroni.

Cyclins, CDKs, and checkpoints

Progress through the cycle is driven by cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs), enzymes that are active only when bound to a cyclin. Cyclin levels rise and fall each cycle. When enough mitotic cyclin accumulates, it binds CDK to form MPF (mitosis-promoting factor), which phosphorylates proteins that launch mitosis; cyclin is then destroyed and MPF activity crashes so the cell can finish dividing.

Three checkpoints stop the cycle if something is wrong. The G1 checkpoint asks whether the cell is big enough and has growth signals such as platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF). The G2 checkpoint asks whether DNA replication is complete and undamaged. The M-spindle checkpoint holds anaphase until every kinetochore is attached to spindle microtubules. Tumor-suppressor proteins such as p53 and Rb enforce these stops; when they are mutated, damaged cells keep dividing, which is a hallmark of cancer.

Mitosis versus meiosis

Meiosis is a reduction division. After one round of DNA replication the cell divides twice, turning one diploid (2n) cell into four haploid (n) cells. In prophase I homologous chromosomes pair and non-sister chromatids exchange segments by crossing over. In metaphase I each homologous pair lines up independently of the others (independent assortment), and in anaphase I the homologs, not the sisters, separate. Meiosis II then separates sister chromatids. If homologs or sisters fail to separate (nondisjunction), gametes end up with an extra or a missing chromosome.

MitosisMeiosis
Divisions after one S phase12
Homologs pair (synapsis)?NoYes, prophase I
Crossing overRareCommon, prophase I
What separates in anaphaseSister chromatidsHomologs (I), then sisters (II)
Products2 cells, 2n, identical4 cells, n, genetically different
RoleGrowth, repair, asexual reproductionGametes or spores for sexual life cycles
Two numbers you'll calculate
mitotic index = (cells in prophase + metaphase + anaphase + telophase) ÷ total cells counted
gene–centromere distance (map units) = (% asci showing crossover) ÷ 2

The mitotic index estimates the fraction of a tissue's cells that are dividing at the moment it was fixed. One map unit equals 1% recombinant products. In a Sordaria ascus with a crossover, only half of the spores carry recombinant chromatids, which is why the percentage is divided by 2.

What this simulation models
  • Process: The cell cycle and mitosis in onion root tips, meiosis and crossing over in the fungus Sordaria, and human karyotypes.
  • Included: Each root tip’s mitotic index (control or lectin), phase counts in proportion to how long each phase lasts, the crossover frequency between the spore-color gene and its centromere, immature asci, and tip-to-tip variation and counting noise. Design runs add lectin dose, salt, pH, temperature and nematodes.
  • Simplified or left out: Cells are drawn, so phases are easier to identify than on a real slide. The design dose-response curves are illustrative guesses, not measured data. Real slides have overlapping cells and uneven staining.
Pre-lab check

Before you start

These questions review key ideas and the calculations you will do later. Check each answer; the explanation appears after you check.

Part 1 · Modeling mitosis

Move the chromosomes yourself

Before you begin: Look at where the chromosomes are before advancing. Use the model controls to observe how their positions change.

Need a quick science reminder?

Sister chromatids are identical copies joined at a centromere. Describe what you observe before naming the phase.

Controls

maternalpaternal
Full procedure

This cell has 2n = 4: a long and a short pair of homologous chromosomes. Blue beads came from the mother, orange from the father, and the dark block in each strand is the centromere. Step through the cycle. In metaphase you drag chromosomes onto the plate; in anaphase you drag each chromatid to a pole. Try sending both sisters to the same pole once to see what happens.

Stage: G1

Chromosomes (count)4
DNA molecules (count)4
Daughter cells (count)—

Record what the model shows

Fill in the table for this 2n = 4 cell (open the Data tab beside the scene). Count a chromosome by its centromeres. DNA amount is in units of c, where 1c is the DNA in one haploid set.

not checked

Put real cells in order

These are stained onion root-tip cells at 400×. Click one card and then another to swap them, until they run in order from interphase to cytokinesis. Then check.

Think about it

Part 2 · Effects of environment on mitosis

Does a fungal lectin speed up mitosis in root tips?

Soybean crops did poorly during three wet years, and their roots were stunted. A lectin-like protein, possibly secreted by a soil fungus, was found around the roots. Lectins are proteins that bind specific carbohydrates, and some act as mitogens that push cells into mitosis; tissue that divides too fast can be weak. You will test the idea with onion bulbs, which grow roots more easily than soybeans. One jar of bulbs grew in sand wet with water (control); the other grew in sand wet with lectin solution (PHA-M, 10 mg in 200 mL).

Controls

Root tips from
Root tip
Click a cell to mark it as
More options

Squash procedure steps

I interphase · P prophase · M metaphase · A anaphase · T telophase. Count only whole cells inside the field.

Interphase (cells)0
Prophase (cells)0
Metaphase (cells)0
Anaphase (cells)0
Telophase (cells)0
Unmarked (cells)0
Mitotic index (%)—

Table 1 · Onion root-tip cell phase data

Your recorded tips fill the Data tab beside the scene (control group and lectin-treated group).

Class data

One group's three tips are not enough to beat the noise. Pool your counts with the rest of the class (seven other lab groups, simulated).

Control MI, mean ± SD (%)—
Lectin MI, mean ± SD (%)—

Chi-square test

Null hypothesis: the lectin has no effect, so treated roots have the same proportion of cells in mitosis as control roots. There are two ways to get expected values; both have df = 1 and a critical value of 3.84 at p = 0.05.

Method

Part 3 · Loss of cell cycle control in cancer

Do cancer cells have different chromosomes?

Cancer can begin when tumor-suppressor genes such as p53 or Rb are mutated and checkpoints stop working. Before you look, write a hypothesis about how the chromosomes of a cancer cell might differ from a normal cell's and how that might connect to how cancer cells behave.

Controls

Cells
View
Full procedure

Click each chromosome once to tally it (click again to untick). Arranging into a karyotype keeps your marks.

Chromosomes you've clicked (count)0

Record your counts and observations

Enter a count for each cell type in the Data tab beside the scene, add what you notice, then check your counts.

Case 1 · HeLa cells

HeLa cells came from the cervical tumor of Henrietta Lacks in 1951 and were grown without her knowledge or consent. They were the first human cells to divide indefinitely in culture and still are used in labs worldwide. Her tumor cells carry DNA from human papillomavirus 18 (HPV-18), whose E6 and E7 proteins disable p53 and Rb.

Case 2 · Philadelphia chromosome

Chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML) cells often contain a Philadelphia chromosome. Switch to CML, arrange the karyotype, and compare pairs 9 and 22 closely with the normal cell.

Part 4 · Modeling meiosis

Crossing over, independent assortment, and nondisjunction

Controls

Beads below the centromere; gene A sits at bead 4.
More options

At metaphase I, click a tetrad in the picture, or use these buttons, to flip which homolog faces each pole.

Full procedure

The same 2n = 4 cell now undergoes meiosis. The long chromosome carries gene A (mother's allele A in blue, father's allele a in orange) on the ringed bead four beads below the centromere; the short chromosome carries gene B/b. Choose whether a crossover happens and where, flip tetrads at metaphase I, and add nondisjunction if you like. Then step through to the four gametes.

Interphase (G1) ·

Many meioses at once

One meiosis is a single draw. Run 200 meioses with random tetrad orientation and a chiasma in the long pair 60% of the time, and look at the four gamete types in the Graph tab.

Part 5 · Meiosis and crossing over in Sordaria

How far is the tan gene from its centromere?

Sordaria fimicola is a fungus whose haploid hyphae fuse where two strains meet on a plate. The brief diploid zygote undergoes meiosis and then one mitosis inside a sac called an ascus, giving eight spores lined up in the order the nuclei divided. You crossed wild type (+, black spores) with tan (tn). Without a crossover between the spore-color gene and the centromere, the alleles separate in meiosis I and the ascus shows a 4:4 pattern. A crossover delays separation to meiosis II, giving 2:2:2:2 or 2:4:2.

Controls

Click an ascus to score it as

Record each scored field once. To collect another field, choose New squash / next field.

Full procedure

Scrape perithecia from where the strains meet, squash under a cover slip, and look at 400×. Score only mature asci whose eight spores you can see clearly. Pale asci are immature.

4:4 scored (asci)0
Crossover scored (asci)0
Mature, unscored (asci)0
Recorded so far (asci)0

Table 3 · Analysis of results

Your recorded fields are in the Data tab beside the scene, and the class results are in the Graph tab.

Count at least 50 asci. Then calculate from your totals:

Class data

Designing and conducting your investigation

What else in the soil changes the rate of mitosis?

Choose one biotic or abiotic factor that might raise or lower the mitotic index in root tips. Plan your levels, replicates, and controls before you run anything. Each tip is scored automatically here so you can focus on design and analysis.

Controls

Levels to test
More options

Analyzing results

Make sense of your data

Need to revisit root-tip cell counts and phase identification? Review the investigation steps before interpreting your results.

Observed vs. expected cells

Observed: the number of cells you actually counted in each phase.

Expected: the number predicted by your comparison distribution, scaled to the same total number of cells.

Record your counts before calculating proportions or comparing distributions.

How do I interpret my mitosis and chi-square results?
  1. Compare the two root-tip groups. Use the proportion of cells in mitosis, not just the total number counted, to compare control and lectin-treated roots.
  2. Check observed and expected values. Each category needs its own observed count and expected count. Use the same overall sample size for the comparison.
  3. Interpret chi-square carefully. A larger chi-square statistic means a larger difference between observed and expected counts. Use the appropriate degrees of freedom and significance threshold before deciding whether the difference is statistically significant.
  4. Support your claim. Cite specific counts or proportions, state whether the data support the claim, and identify a possible limitation such as sampling or misidentifying cell phases.

A statistically significant difference does not, by itself, prove that lectin caused the change.

Root tips (postlab review)

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Does the fungal lectin increase the proportion of root-tip cells in mitosis?

Sordaria (evaluating results)

Chi-square calculator

Use this for any goodness-of-fit test, such as your own design data or the 200-meiosis run.

Scientific reasoning self-check (optional)

Review your own explanation before submitting. These checkpoints are reminders, not automatic grading or evaluation of your writing.

  • My claim compares the relevant control and treatment or meiosis results.
  • I cite cell counts, proportions, or spore patterns rather than only conclusions.
  • I connect the pattern to cell division or crossing over using the correct mechanism.
  • I discuss sampling, identification, or statistical limitations.

If something is missing, revisit your measurements and revise your explanation. Your writing is not automatically scored here.

Evaluate and extend

Where can you go from here?

Wrap up

Save and hand in your work